Centiq Blog

Centiq Blog

Feb 10
2010

POWER7 vs POWER6 taking a closer look at the prices

Posted by: Robin Webster in Infrastructure

Robin Webster

"With POWER7 you get twice the performance, use half the power and four times the virtual capacity for the same price as POWER6". IBM 08 Feb 2010.

Now IBM have officially announced the IBM System P POWER7 range I thought I'd test some of IBM's bold claims for performance vs purchase price, power consumption and space savings for the new POWER7 range by comparing it with the POWER6 range. Have they really changed that much? The move from IBM System P POWER5 to IBM System P POWER6 was a great improvement in performance and brought with it some great new features, but the price was still very high and left open the door to a price contest with x86 alternatives and some challenging total cost of ownership (TCO) comparisons. I thought I'd start by taking a look at the really popular entry point in the POWER range - the 550 (4U rack mount).  First thing to note is that it is now called the 750 (finally the numbers make sense!) So how does it compare on price/performance with the POWER6?

I'm using the IBM POWER relative performance metric rPerf to create comparable systems. The actual performance you get from these systems will depend on how well your software/middleware makes use of parallel processes to drive the four threads per core capability of POWER7, but the rPerf is a great place to start.

Lets look at the lower entry point to begin. The smallest 750 has six 3.3Ghz cores in a single socket giving an rPerf figure of 70. For the equivalent POWER6 system the nearest is eight 4.2Ghz cores in 4 sockets giving your an rPerf of 68.

In both the entry and high-end examples I have tried to create a realistic set of resources so that we have a fair comparison. I have chosen the following specification for both a POWER6 and POWER7 system

  • 32GB RAM
  • 2 internal disks
  • 2 SAS interfaces
  • on board Ethernet +2 port PCI card
  • 2 x 2 port 4GB Fibre
  • No PowerVM
  • 3 yr SWMA

In this example the POWER6 list price adds up to £124,650, the POWER7 price list price is £50,917.

It's worth noting that the 750 has 3 more CPU sockets to expand into, and greater headroom for memory.

So how does a fully expanded 750 compare with POWER6 systems?

The biggest fastest POWER7 750 is the 32 core 3.55Ghz 4 socket machine with an earth shattering rPerf of 331. To get this compute power form a POWER6 machine you have to leapfrog up the range to the p595 with 35 5.0Ghz cores giving you an rPerf of 335. You can probably guess which is going to be cheaper, but lets work through the example for fun. (I don't get out much these days anyway)

Again trying to make a real world example I have added the following specification to both examples.

  • 512GB RAM
  • 1 I/O Drawer
  • 8 73GB disks
  • Four SAS interfaces
  • 4 x 4 port PCIe 1Gb Ethernet
  • 4 x 2 port PCIe 8Gb FC
  • PowerVM Standard
  • 3yr SWMA

For my example configs the POWER6 p595 list price is £2,846,828 and the POWER7 750 list price is £427,661. Obviously there are some advantages with a p595 and in some circumstances the p595 architecture may produce better performance, but with such a dramatic reduction in purchase cost coupled with reduced data centre space and low power consumption (1950W for the 750, something like 6000W+ for the 595) it has to be worth a look.

Next Generation POWER7 VIOS, Read Robins blog about these: Click here

View in-depth IBM POWER7 and IBM POWER6 appliances of your choice: Click here

Speak to one of our technical experts now to see how Centiq can help your business by requesting a "call back" using the button to the right, or calling us on 0115 951 9666

Hits: 6204
Trackback(0)
Comments (3)Add Comment
Rob Fallows
...
written by Rob Fallows, 15:10 February 11, 2010
Those price differences are quite staggering. For more background on the technology behind POWER7, there's an interesting article here on The Register: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2...ip_launch/
Robin Webster
...
written by Robin Webster, 19:00 February 11, 2010
I know, dramatic price drop. And what's even more exciting is that currently this 750 system fits within the 4 socket limit for the Oracle Standard Licence which will only cost you £10555 per socket, that's £1319 per core, compared with the £28947 per core for enterprise edition! I'm not sure how long this will last so get in there quick everyone!
Robin Webster
...
written by Robin Webster, 19:04 February 11, 2010
Oh and if you want more info on the Oracle licence rules/prices take a look at
http://www.centiq.co.uk/calcul...oice.html

Write comment

security code
Enter the displayed characters


busy

Request more information

Want us to contact you right now?

Leave your details and we'll call you Immediately during work hours.

Name: *
Company:
Phone: *

Bloggers

Emily MalbonEmily Malbon:
Helpdesk and Support

Rebecca PritchardRebecca Pritchard:
Project Management

Robin WebsterRobin Webster:
UNIX

Steven CalvertSteven Calvert:
Storage

Steve StringerSteve Stringer:
Blade and SAP BWA

Glyn HeathGlyn Heath:
IT Industry

Tags

tecniq_with_textv2ibm-premier-business-markhi-res monitiq logohp partner 2011accredit_uk_logo v2